CONSTITUTIONAL CRISIS

Welcome to our feature on the proposed EU Constitution. There are some points to bear in mind.

First - the terms 'Constitution' and 'Constitutional Treaty' get used interchangeably. Any changes to the current Treaty establishing the EU (The Treaty of Nice) are decided by governments ('intergovernmentally') who will sign a new Treaty.

Second - the European Union has already got a Constitution of sorts - although like the British Constitution - it is not all in a single document. The term acquis communautaire is used to summarise the current body of Treaties, European Community legislation and European Court judgements passed over the years. Most significantly this contains a ratchet that any powers transferred by member states stay at a European level.

Third - the official EU documents approved by its Convention are subject to agreement between EU member states' governments and are therefore subject to change. There are 25 members and any could insist on changes - although history also shows that compromises take place.

Fourth - some countries, notably Denmark and the Republic of Ireland require referendums for what will be constitutional changes for them. Treaty ratification has to be unanimous, otherwise the new [Constitutional] Treaty does not come into force.

However - there is speculation that the Governments will threaten to break ('abrogate') the current Treaty with those members that do not (for whatever reason) ratify the new Treaty. This would in theory require them to accept the new Treaty or leave the EU. Watch this space





Irish EU Presidency, to June 2004 Latest proposals
Critical analysis - recommended EU Convention website (2003)
Our article on the first (2003) draft Why you can't trust New Labour
UK Parliament - Constitution for the
European Union (Referendum) Bill
Bill debated, Hansard 23.4.04
(see text halfway down)
Referendum Fever hits the UK
Coverage from May 2003
Warning against complacency,
Jeffrey Donaldson MP speech to Bruges Group
Referendum 2004
Link to popular campaign
The European Legal Order
"EC Law supreme now"?
Britain's historic Constitution revealed,
Q+A feature
Life after EU?
What if Britain made a clean break?
New Alliance Index Page New Alliance Home Page



Date this page first compiled: 22 June 2003. Updated 15 May 2004